TikTok Lite vs TikTok: A Disparity in Safety Features
Odanga Madung, a Mozilla fellow and coauthor of the report, emphasized the importance of labeling as a trust and safety tactic used by platforms. He highlighted that the absence of guardrails in TikTok Lite means that users in poorer markets are provided with less information to distinguish fake content from real compared to users in wealthier regions.
In response to the report, TikTok stated that content breaking the platform’s rules is removed from TikTok Lite just as it is from the main app, and that the company offers numerous safety features. However, the report’s findings have sparked questions about why TikTok chose to omit features that make the platform safer for users in the Lite version.
The Role of TikTok AI and Labeling
Lite versions of apps have been used by companies to increase market share in areas with high data costs or less advanced phones. TikTok Lite, which can run on 2G and 3G networks, has rapidly expanded to Southeast Asian markets and garnered over 1 billion downloads. Payal Arora, professor of inclusive AI cultures at Utrecht University, emphasized the critical nature of Lite versions in getting low-income users on board, especially in regions where “data is the currency in this AI-driven and AI-hungry market.”
Researchers discovered significant differences between the Lite and main versions of the app, including the absence of labeling for Covid-19 related content and truncated captions in TikTok Lite. These findings underscore concerns about the potential impact of these differences on user empowerment and the spread of content beyond the TikTok platform.
Implications for User Empowerment and Content Spread
The implications of the report’s findings highlight the need for continued scrutiny and discussion around the safety and protection of users, particularly in regions where Lite versions of apps are prevalent. The impact of these differences in safety features on user empowerment and the potential spread of content beyond the TikTok platform remains a subject of concern.
Madung expressed concerns that the damage caused by a lack of labels and moderation will not be limited to TikTok Lite users alone, as content created on TikTok is often downloaded and shared on other platforms such as WhatsApp or Instagram Reels.
In summary, the TikTok Lite app’s lack of AI labeling and other safety features poses significant risks for users in the Global South. Addressing these issues is crucial for ensuring that all users, regardless of their economic status, are equally protected from misleading and potentially harmful content.